Will whenever schedules are provided, he is offered which have 1 day of the month you to definitely do maybe not fits with this day as it in the real history. One particular analogy takes place in Harry Potter additionally the Prisoner off Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney means sixteen October given that Friday, even when 16 Oct 1993 is a tuesday.
There are even contradictions for the instructions in this region. Instance, inside Harry Potter and Goblet off Fire, both 1 September and you can 2 September are provided given that Mondays and you may, during the Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner out-of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is determined to the 20 April, but cautious parsing of text message implies that this may provides taken place no later than simply March.
Also, for the Harry Potter and also the Cup away from Fire they claim that the Champions was selected toward Tuesday 30 October, but 29 Oct is actually a friday inside 1994.
Inside the a bankruptcy proceeding off Quidditch From Years, people say the earliest Quidditch Business Cup happened during the 1473. Whether your championship is actually stored the several years, which conflicts to the declaration inside the Goblet out of Flames that the 1994 Community Cup is actually the fresh new 422nd. In the event that Quidditch Through the Years is right, the latest 422nd Quidditch Community Cup perform in reality fall-in the entire year 3161, however if Goblet away from Fire is useful, the first World Mug was kept for the 306.
Historic difficulties [ ]
Although the show, with respect to the schedule based on the brand new Chamber out-of Secrets site, is set on the nineties, the collection commonly looks as though it’s set in meet canadian women for marriage the brand new later 1990s so you can mid-2000s, roughly concurrent on the book of the instructions. Inside the Harry Potter and also the Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge uses a male pronoun to mention for the “predecessor” of your own Finest Minister of your own Uk. Depending on the more than timeline, this should occur in the summertime of 1996, in the event the Primary Minister was John Biggest, whoever quick predecessor is actually a lady (‘s the reason basic meeting with Fudge, the publication says new election, however, Significant was not initial chose and just grabbed more once Thatcher retired.
It is possible, but not impractical, one to Fudge is making reference to an even more faraway predecessor, as the Thatcher took office before Fudge purportedly turned Minister to have Secret. (Even if one could envision a situation in which Fudge are delegated because of the Minister having Wonders in order to satisfy into Best Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in an inferior office.) On the other hand, this new character and you will reputation of the prime Minister represented appears to a great deal more closely match that Tony Blair than just away from John Big. A post on the Every day Send cards that Rowling is actually close into the next-Chancellor of Exchequer Gordon Brown (often considered an opponent in order to Blair’s management of the Work People, exactly who been successful your and turned into Perfect Minister), which she might have been attempting to let you know Blair’s terrible top. In the event the guides was basically invest connect with publication go out from Philosopher’s Brick, then that it event manage occur in 2002 (shortly after Blair turned Primary Minister).
However, it actually was later stated that twenty-two November is actually a saturday, which it was in 1994
A comparable problem pertains to Nicolas Flamel, who was simply said as being 665 at the time of brand new basic book, however, Nicolas Flamel was a bona fide historical profile and you will would not have reached one to years up until 1996, within go out the first guide try typed. The latest rebuttal for it is the fact that the day the newest “real” Nicolas Flamel came into this world doesn’t correspond with the Nicolas Flamel away from Harry Potter.
An alternative state is present regarding Rubeus Hagrid’s period because Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is implied regarding show that Hagrid obtained you to definitely standing in this many years out of their expulsion out-of college in the 1942. However in one to scene off Harry Potter together with Goblet regarding Fire, Molly Weasley reminisces on the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper apparently overlap with Molly’s years at school, it seems impractical you to definitely she recalls a past gamekeeper. not, it’s possible you to definitely Hagrid don’t feel a beneficial gamekeeper quickly immediately following becoming expelled, but rather started due to the fact Ogg’s assistant. This is exactly plausible because whenever Harry believes that he commonly end up being expelled getting flying towards broomstick instead of permission in his first year, he magic if the however be allowed to remain on since the Hagrid’s secretary.
